Looking after your pool can be a labor-intensive task, especially if you are cleaning with a manual cleaner. Luckily pool maintenance has got a lot easier. An automatic cleaner is an ideal solution if you want to spend more time enjoying your pool and less time working up a sweat cleaning it. You want your automatic cleaner to get to every nook and cranny, leaving no mess behind. It also needs to be cost-effective and convenient. So, what is the best type of automatic pool cleaner for you and best suited to the needs of your pool

Robotic Pool Cleaner

Robotic Pool Cleaner

Various factors about your pool will influence what is best for you, such as the size of your pool and the common types of debris you will find. Let’s look and compare the pros and cons of the two most popular cleaners, the robotic pool cleaners versus the suction pool cleaners and see which one best serves the needs of your pool.


Suction Pool Cleaners

Suction pool cleaners get to work on the surface of your pool, removing dirt and debris using the dedicated suction line in your pool. Moving automatically and randomly around your pool’s floor and walls, the cleaner is great at picking up even the finest of debris. It draws in water and dirt, taking it to your pools main filter which does the cleaning, and deposits the clean water back into your pool. You will rarely have to clean your pool manually any longer as the cleaner takes care of most jobs.

Suction Pool Cleaner vs Robotic Pool Cleaner

Suction Pool Cleaner

What you’ll like

Suction pool cleaners are the most affordable automatic pool cleaners, and they offer pool owners good value for money. There are fewer mechanical parts on these cleaners, limiting the chances of something malfunctioning. Suction pool cleaners are easy to maintain and to install.

What you won’t like

Because the cleaner uses your existing pool pump and filtration system it will place extra pressure on the system which may lead to problems. You will be required to control the hose that connects to the cleaner to your system. Every time you use the cleaner, it will have to be manually connected and packed away after you are done. These cleaners sometimes get stuck on certain obstacles like leaves and sticks and may not get into the hard to reach places. They could require occasional supervision, for instance when they get stuck on pool steps or in a corner.

This is the best pool cleaner if you are looking for something that is affordable, easy to maintain and leaves you with a clean pool with a little bit of effort.

Robotic Pool Cleaner vs Suction Pool Cleaner

Robotic Pool Cleaner

Robotic Pool Cleaners

Robotic pool cleaners run on electricity, bypassing your pool’s filtration system. They operate without putting any further pressure on your pools filtration system and are equipped with its own onboard pump and filter. The robotic pool cleaner’s “plug and play” is extremely convenient too. Various cleaning programs can be controlled through its computer chip and conform to the needs of your pool. The cleaner not only scrubs and sucks the surface of your pool, extracting large and fine debris, but it also cleans the pool walls, steps, and even the waterline.

Suction Pool Cleaner

Suction Pool Cleaner

What you’ll like

You will be hard pressed to find a cleaner that is as thorough at cleaning as the robotic pool cleaner. You can say goodbye to ever having to do any manual cleaning as it completely cleans the entire pool. They are extremely energy efficient, reducing costs in the long run. The thin electric cable it operates with means you don’t have to deal with a balky hose, making the machine light and efficient. Because the cleaner bypasses your pool’s filtration system, it means there will be less wear and tear on your pool equipment. They are suited to most pools, guaranteeing you sparkling clean water all year-round.

Robotic Pool Cleaner

Robotic Pool Cleaner

What you won’t like

The upfront cost is high. Although it will save you a lot of time and money in the long run, these cleaners are the most expensive on the market. They are very easy to maintain. The filtration system will be required to be emptied when needed, and that’s about it.

You will be hard pressed to beat the robotic pool cleaner if you can afford it. They are reliable and powerful. It is the ideal cleaner that gets the job done with little to no complications.

Suction Pool Cleaner

Suction Pool Cleaner



Overall Recommended Robotic Pool Cleaners
Best of the Best! "Budget" Pick Also Great
DOLPHIN Nautilus CC Supreme Automatic Robotic Pool Cleaner- The Next Generation of Pool Cleaning with WiFi for Control from Anywhere, Ideal for Swimming Pools up to 50 Feet Dolphin Nautilus CC Plus Automatic Robotic Pool Cleaner with Easy to Clean Large Top Load Filter Cartridges and Tangle-Free Swivel Cord, Ideal for In-ground Swimming Pools up to 50 Feet. DOLPHIN Oasis Z5i Robotic Pool Cleaner with Bluetooth Control for Stress Free Pool Cleaning, Ideal for In-ground Swimming Pools up to 50 Feet.
Dolphin Nautilus CC Supreme Dolphin Nautilus CC Plus Dolphin Oasis Z5i
 • In-ground Swimming Pools
 • Pool Size: Up to 50 ft.
 • 1,5 | 2,5 | 3,5 hrs Cleaning Time
 • WIFI Connectivity
 • Twin Cartridges - Extra Large
 • In-ground Swimming Pools
 • Pool Size: Up to 50 ft.
 • 2 hr Cleaning Time
 • -
 • Twin Cartridges - Large
 • In-ground Swimming Pools
 • Pool Size: Up to 50 ft.
 • 2,5 hr Cleaning Time
 • Bluetooth Connectivity
 • Twin Cartridges - Extra Large





Newsletter Signup

The Best of Gardinator in Your Inbox!

We’d love to stay in touch, sign up for the Gardinator team to contact you with great news, content and offers.

*